Judge tosses Staten Island Amazon worker suit over COVID-19 policies

A federal judge has dismissed a lawsuit from Amazon workers in New York City who sued the company over its handling of the coronavirus crisis.

In dismissing the lawsuit from the employees at a massive warehouse on Staten Island, dubbed “JFK8,” Judge Brian Cogan ruled late Monday that the Occupational Safety and Health Administration would be a better avenue to handle the e-tailer’s pandemic policies than a federal courtroom.

“No doubt, shutting down JFK8 completely during the pandemic while continuing to provide employees with pay and benefits would be the best protection against contagion at the workplace,” Cogan acknowledged in his ruling, but added that the warehouse workers’ claims “go to the heart of OSHA’s expertise and discretion.”

The lawsuit had aimed to hold Amazon legally accountable for what workers call insufficient efforts to protect them from the virus.

One of the plaintiffs, Barbara Chandler, contracted the virus in March at the JFK8 fulfillment center and brought it home to her family, the complaint read. It eventually infected her cousin — whom Chandler found dead in the bathroom less than a month later — and her son, who was also a plaintiff.

The complaint also accuses Amazon of prioritizing productivity over safety at the Staten Island warehouse by failing to keep workstations clean, discouraging workers from washing their hands, and tacitly encouraging them to work while sick.

Amazon’s Staten Island warehouse has seen multiple labor protests since the start of the pandemic. Amazon last week said that by the end of the quarter, it will have spent more than $11 billion on COVID-related expenses, including $4 billion in the next three months alone.

All countries
194,616,521
Total confirmed cases
Updated on July 25, 2021 3:21 pm
Italy
4,317,415
Total confirmed cases
Updated on July 25, 2021 3:21 pm
Spain
4,280,429
Total confirmed cases
Updated on July 25, 2021 3:21 pm
Iran
3,691,432
Total confirmed cases
Updated on July 25, 2021 3:21 pm
Germany
3,762,194
Total confirmed cases
Updated on July 25, 2021 3:21 pm

Latest Updates

Without Backpackers to Pick Them, Crops Rot by the Ton in Australia

SHEPPARTON, Australia — Peter Hall ran a hand over the Gala apples sitting in a wooden crate on his orchard in southeastern Australia, lamenting...

U.S. Will Have Enough COVID-19 Vaccines for All Adults by End of May, Biden Says

You have reached your limit of 4 free articles. Get unlimited access to TIME.com.99¢ for the first month Subscribe Now You have...

Biden Vows Enough Vaccine ‘for Every Adult American’ by End of May

But Johnson & Johnson and its partners fell behind in their manufacturing. The company was supposed to deliver its first 37 million doses by...

Popular Articles

Without Backpackers to Pick Them, Crops Rot by the Ton in Australia

SHEPPARTON, Australia — Peter Hall ran a hand over the Gala apples sitting in a wooden crate on his orchard in southeastern Australia, lamenting...

U.S. Will Have Enough COVID-19 Vaccines for All Adults by End of May, Biden Says

You have reached your limit of 4 free articles. Get unlimited access to TIME.com.99¢ for the first month Subscribe Now You have...

Biden Vows Enough Vaccine ‘for Every Adult American’ by End of May

But Johnson & Johnson and its partners fell behind in their manufacturing. The company was supposed to deliver its first 37 million doses by...

Twitch gamer Sodapoppin quits fake GTA jobs because they’re too hard

Sometimes being a fake fast-food restaurant manager can be as taxing as being a real one. This is especially true when you also have pretend...

Sarkozy says could take corruption appeal to European human rights court

France's former president Nicolas Sarkozy said Tuesday that he might consider taking his appeal against a corruption conviction to the European Court of...

Where Biden’s Foreign Policy Is Taking the U.S.

One day before the administration announced its decision on Saudi Arabia, Biden gave the first major indication of his presidency that he would be...

Interviews